All comparisons

Methodology

SoWhichOne uses mathematical models to compare the same trip, energy demand, time period, number of uses or product quantity. The starting values are examples. Enter figures for your situation and use the results to see how each assumption affects the comparison.

How to read the results

Cash savings equal the higher comparable cost minus the lower one. For unequal, non-negative costs, percentage savings equal that difference divided by the higher cost, multiplied by 100. Package comparisons use unit prices for the percentage. A zero cost is 100% less than a positive cost. Equal costs are shown as a tie, and a negative net cost is compared using cash savings only. Calculations use unrounded values before formatting.

A break-even point identifies an input or time at which the modeled costs meet. A whole-use threshold may be the first use where buying already costs less. Some scenarios have no feasible crossing or are equal throughout. Actual prices, usage and conditions can change, and a lower modeled cost is only one factor alongside reliability, convenience, comfort and costs outside the comparison.

Units, currency and tariffs

The transport calculations use kilometres and consumption per 100 km internally. One mile is 1.609344 km. One US gallon is 3.785411784 litres and one UK gallon is 4.54609 litres. For liquid-fuel vehicles displayed in MPG, litres per 100 km equal 100 × litres per gallon ÷ (1.609344 × MPG). Fuel price per gallon is price per litre × litres per gallon. Plug-in hybrid liquid fuel and CNG are displayed as volume and mass per 100 km or 100 mi. Electric consumption and cost per distance are displayed per 100 km or per mile.

Use one currency for every amount. The currency setting changes the label and display format. It does not convert money. Electricity prices are entered per kWh. Include applicable taxes and usage-based network charges in the rate you enter. Fixed charges are outside the model.

Compare driving costs

Choose a powertrain for each car and enter the same driving distance. Enter battery use in kWh per 100 km for an EV, fuel consumption in litres per 100 km or kilograms per 100 km for CNG, and fuel price per litre or kilogram. For plug-in hybrids, enter both consumption figures averaged over the whole trip. Both cars use the same electricity tariff and charging loss percentage when applicable. The example uses 0% loss.

Fuel cost per km = fuel use per 100 km × fuel price ÷ 100. Grid electricity per km = battery use per 100 km ÷ [100 × (1 − loss % ÷ 100)]. Cost per km = fuel cost per km + grid electricity per km × electricity price, using the applicable terms. Multiply by the trip distance for the total or by the optional annual distance for annual energy costs.

The break-even electricity price = (B’s fuel cost per km − A’s fuel cost per km) ÷ (A’s grid kWh per km − B’s grid kWh per km). If a car can plug in, the calculator shows a finite price at zero or above when one exists. Equal grid consumption gives either equality at every price or no crossing, depending on fuel costs. A negative threshold is outside the model. Purely fuel-powered pairs have no electric tariff to compare. At zero distance both trip totals are zero, while the threshold still describes costs per km.

The model covers fuel and electricity. Road tolls, parking and other route-specific charges are excluded, as are vehicle purchase, depreciation, maintenance, insurance, financing and other ownership costs. Temperature, speed and driving patterns can change consumption.

Open calculator

Home vs public charging

Enter home and public tariffs per kWh and each location’s charging loss. The example losses are 10% at home and 5% in public. Enter either battery energy in kWh or a trip distance and battery consumption in kWh per 100 km. In distance mode, battery demand = distance in km × consumption ÷ 100.

For each location, effective cost per battery kWh = tariff ÷ (1 − loss % ÷ 100). Total cost = battery demand × effective cost. Per-distance costs multiply the effective price by battery consumption per distance. The annual comparison uses annual driving distance (15,000 km in the example), even in battery-energy mode. With an optional home share, mixed cost = home-only cost × home share + public-only cost × the remaining share. The share refers to energy delivered to the battery.

For any positive battery demand, costs are equal when home and public effective prices are equal. At zero demand the selected totals are both zero. The calculator shows effective prices and costs without solving for a separate break-even tariff. It excludes equipment, installation, session fees, subscriptions, parking and idle fees. Real losses vary with the charger, vehicle and conditions.

Open calculator

Heat pump vs electric heating

Enter useful heat demand in kWh, the heat pump’s COP or seasonal COP (SCOP), and the pump’s electricity price. COP is the ratio of useful heat delivered to electricity consumed. Resistance heating is modeled at 100% efficiency. You can enter a separate resistance tariff and annual heat demand. If left blank, these use the pump tariff and the main heat demand respectively.

Heat-pump electricity = heat demand ÷ COP. Resistance electricity = heat demand. Multiply each by its own tariff. The annual estimate substitutes annual heat demand in the same formulas. For positive demand, costs are equal if the pump tariff ÷ COP equals the resistance tariff. Both totals are zero at zero demand. The calculator shows operating costs and does not calculate equipment payback.

Equipment purchase, installation, maintenance, financing and lifespan are outside the model. Use a seasonal COP to estimate annual use. Outdoor temperatures, supply temperature, defrosting and backup heat can affect the achievable COP.

Open calculator

Old vs efficient appliance

Enter each appliance’s annual electricity use in kWh, the electricity price, the replacement purchase price and a whole number of years. The current appliance is already owned. Its total = annual kWh × price × years. Replacement total = its annual kWh × price × years + upfront purchase price.

Annual operating savings = (current annual kWh − replacement annual kWh) × price. With positive operating savings, payback in years = purchase price ÷ annual savings, even if this is beyond the selected period. A free replacement with positive savings pays back immediately. With no purchase cost and equal operating costs, the totals are equal throughout. With equal or higher running costs, a paid replacement does not pay for itself. A free replacement that costs more to run has no savings-based payback.

The chart shows cumulative costs at selected years. Electricity price and usage stay constant. Repairs, resale, financing and changes in lifespan are outside the model. Use annual consumption for comparable usage, converting any per-cycle label with your expected cycles per year.

Open calculator

Buy vs rent

Enter the purchase price, total maintenance for the comparison period, optional expected resale value (zero by default), a rental price per use or period, and a whole number of uses or periods. Use the same rental unit throughout, such as a day or a job.

Net ownership cost = purchase price + maintenance − resale. Renting = rental price × number of uses. Enter ownership and rental charges that apply to the same scenario. The calculator does not add financing, insurance, storage, delivery, deposits or other fees automatically. It treats maintenance and resale as fixed estimates over the comparison and does not discount future cash flows.

With a positive ownership cost and rental rate, divide ownership cost by the rental rate and round up to the first whole use where buying costs the same or less. If rent is free and ownership costs money, there is no break-even. If ownership is zero or negative, buying is as cheap or cheaper from the start. Both options tie at every use when both costs are zero. A negative net cost means expected resale exceeds purchase and maintenance. An exceptionally small positive rental price can put the threshold beyond the range that can represent whole uses reliably.

Open calculator

Compare package prices

Multiply the amount per package by the whole number of packages. Convert weights to kilograms and volumes to litres. Multiply grams or millilitres by 0.001, pounds by 0.45359237, and weight ounces by 0.45359237 ÷ 16. Multiply US fluid ounces by 0.0295735295625 and UK fluid ounces by 0.0284130625. Item counts stay in whole items. Both products need units of the same kind.

The subtotal is the price per package × number of packages. A percentage discount multiplies the subtotal by (1 − discount ÷ 100). A fixed discount is subtracted once from the full subtotal and cannot exceed it. Each product can use one discount type. Blank discount amounts count as zero. Free products and 100% discounts are allowed. Package size and package count must be positive.

Effective unit price = checkout total ÷ normalized purchase quantity. The absolute difference is the higher unit price minus the lower one. Percentage savings = difference ÷ higher unit price × 100. Equal rates are a tie. To estimate savings for an equal quantity, multiply the unit price difference by the smaller of the two purchase quantities. This assumes the effective rate applies proportionally, even if stores only sell whole packages. The checkout totals reflect the actual package counts entered.

Prices should use the same currency and include any applicable tax. The model assumes identical package prices within each option and excludes delivery fees and deposits. Calculations use unrounded values. The display rounds money to currency precision (with extra digits for amounts below 0.01), percentages to one decimal place and quantities to at most two decimal places, with extra digits for very small quantities. Rounded prices can look the same even when the underlying rates differ.

Open calculator

Regional settings

Prices use your selected currency. Enter prices in that currency.

Appearance